Executive pension plan vs personal pension Ireland, side by side
Both are funded by the company tax-efficiently, and both are invested for retirement. The difference is who controls the scheme, how much can go in, what happens when the company changes, and what can be done at retirement. For most company directors, an executive pension plan gives more funding headroom and more retirement flexibility. A personal pension or PRSA is simpler and travels with the individual. The choice between an executive pension plan and a personal pension in Ireland comes down to how much the director wants to contribute and how long they plan to stay in the company.
The tax argument for company contributions (salary versus dividend, deductibility, benefit-in-kind) is covered separately in the 6 November article and is not re-argued here. This piece is about the vehicle itself.
| Dimension | Executive pension plan | Personal pension / PRSA |
|---|---|---|
| Legal structure | One-member occupational scheme, company is trustee or operator | Contract between the individual and the provider |
| Who signs | Company signs the trust deed and scheme rules | Individual signs the application and policy |
| Funding basis | Revenue maximum funding on salary and service | Age-banded percentage of net relevant earnings, capped |
| Ownership on leaving | Tied to the company, needs winding up or transfer | Stays with the individual |
| Retirement options | ARF, annuity, 25% lump sum, flexible drawdown | ARF, annuity, 25% lump sum, flexible drawdown |
Control and structure
An executive pension plan is an occupational pension scheme with a single member. The company establishes it, signs the trust documentation, and acts as trustee or appoints a professional trustee. The director is the beneficiary, not the policyholder. That distinction matters in practice. The scheme belongs to the company, the company makes the contributions, and the company controls the wind-up decision.
A personal pension or PRSA is a direct contract between the individual and the life company or provider. The director signs the application, owns the policy, and can move it without reference to the company. For a sole director running a limited company, the executive plan requires a formal scheme document and annual trustee obligations, but the same person is on both sides of the table, so decisions move quickly. The paperwork is heavier at setup and lighter in ongoing governance than directors often expect.
Funding limits and how much can go in
This is where the two vehicles diverge most. An occupational scheme is funded on a Revenue maximum funding basis, calculated from salary, service, and the retirement age chosen. A director can fund back over past service, which is why a director in their fifties with long service can often put in a multiple of salary in a single year. Personal pensions and PRSAs are instead limited to an age-banded percentage of net relevant earnings, subject to the earnings cap (€115,000 for 2024, per Revenue). A 52-year-old is limited to 35% of earnings under the personal pension route.
Say a 52-year-old sole director takes €100,000 in salary and the company has €150,000 of profit available to fund a pension. Under the personal pension or PRSA route, the age-banded contribution is 35% of €100,000, so €35,000. The remaining €115,000 cannot go in that year through the personal vehicle. Under an executive plan, Revenue maximum funding on salary and 20-plus years of service can support a contribution well above €35,000, often the full €150,000 or close to it, subject to an actuarial funding certificate. That headroom is the single biggest reason a director chooses the executive plan. The exact figure depends on service and the funding test, so it needs to be calculated, not assumed.
Charges and where the break-even sits
A one-member executive plan carries establishment costs (legal and scheme documentation, typically €1,500 to €3,000) and annual trustee and administration fees (often €500 to €1,500, plus fund charges). A PRSA or personal pension usually has no establishment fee and a single annual management charge of 0.5% to 1.5%, depending on the provider and the fund.
| Cost | Executive plan | PRSA / personal pension |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | €1,500 to €3,000 | Nil |
| Annual admin | €500 to €1,500 plus fund charges | 0.5% to 1.5% AMC |
| Break-even pot | Roughly €150,000 to €300,000 | Any pot size |
Below roughly €150,000, the fixed annual cost of the executive plan is a meaningful drag on returns. From around €300,000 upward, the fixed costs shrink as a percentage and the funding headroom usually outweighs them. The break-even is not a single number; it depends on contribution size and how long the scheme runs.
Investment choice and flexibility
Many one-member executive schemes are insured products with a fund menu of 10 to 30 managed funds, not the full market. A self-directed or self-administered scheme opens up direct property, individual equities, and ETFs, but it adds administration and cost, and it needs a professional trustee. Directors often assume the executive plan means total investment freedom; it usually does not unless the self-directed route is chosen deliberately.
A PRSA offers a defined fund range from the provider, typically a mix of managed, passive, and lifestyle options. The range is narrower than a self-directed scheme but wider than a basic insured executive plan. For a director who wants a simple diversified portfolio and no trustee overhead, the PRSA fund range is often enough.
What happens if the company changes
A personal pension travels with the individual. If the company is sold, wound up, or the director moves to a new employer or emigrates, the policy stays in the director’s name and needs no action.
An executive plan is tied to the company. On a sale, the scheme may need to be wound up or transferred to the buyer’s arrangement. On wind-up, the assets must be transferred to another approved arrangement or used to buy benefits. On emigration, the scheme remains an Irish occupational scheme and the director’s options depend on the destination country’s rules and the scheme’s own terms. A new job with a different employer means the scheme can no longer be funded and must be wound up or left dormant. That portability risk is real and should be weighed against the funding headroom.
At retirement and drawdown options
Both vehicles can access an Approved Retirement Fund (ARF), take the 25% tax-free lump sum (subject to the €200,000 lifetime limit), and draw down flexibly. The difference is in the mechanics. An executive plan can allow retirement from age 50 in some circumstances, earlier than the normal PRSA access age, and the scheme rules can be drafted to give the director more control over the timing of the lump sum and the transfer to an ARF. A PRSA follows the standard access rules. For definitions of ARFs and how they work, see the ARF glossary. This article does not cover ARF mechanics in detail.
Decision summary
Choose an executive pension plan if the company has substantial profit to contribute, the director has long service to fund back over, the director wants earlier or more flexible retirement access, and the pot is likely to exceed roughly €150,000.
Choose a personal pension or PRSA if contributions are modest, the director may sell or leave the company within a few years, simplicity and portability matter more than funding headroom, and the pot is likely to stay below the break-even point.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the Revenue maximum funding figure on this salary and service, and how was it calculated?
- What are the total setup and annual costs, including trustee fees and fund charges?
- Is this an insured scheme with a limited fund menu, or a self-directed arrangement?
- What happens to the scheme if the company is sold, wound up, or the director emigrates?
- What retirement age does the scheme allow, and can the director access benefits earlier?
- How does the scheme interact with any existing personal pension or PRSA the director holds?
Pension Advice provides a free company pension review for directors weighing these two vehicles. Revenue rules and funding limits change, so confirm the current figures with Revenue or an adviser before committing.
Frequently asked questions
Can I have both an executive pension plan and a personal pension?
Yes, but Revenue limits apply to the total contributions across both. You should get advice to ensure you do not exceed the maximum funding allowed for your age and income.
Is an executive pension plan suitable for a sole director?
Yes, many sole directors use executive pension plans to maximise company contributions. However, you need to consider the higher setup and running costs compared to a PRSA.
What happens to my executive pension plan if I sell my company?
The plan is an occupational scheme, so it is tied to the company. On a sale, the scheme may need to be wound up or transferred, depending on the deal structure. A personal pension is unaffected by a company sale.